To Muratov D.A. Editor in chief “Novaya Gazeta” 101990, Moscow, Potapovsky per., 3 From: Law firm “Ivanyan and partners”, lawyers of “Gunvor” company of T. Tornqvist and G.N. Timchenko Subject: Publication in “Novaya gazeta” dated 24.08.09 and letters addressed to T. Tornqvist and G.N. Timchenko dated 11.08.09 and 31.08.09. September 4th, 2009. Dear Dmitry Andreyevich,