

by John Helmer, Moscow
@bears_with
Wherever you are, once you are in war, free speech doesn’t exist any longer. Truth telling is replaced by propaganda narratives enforced by censors and security services.
Between the truth and the propaganda there is that burst of 280 characters – 40 to 70 words – which was first invented in 2006 and is known as a tweet. This is published by the social networking company called Twitter Inc at the beginning, and now known as X Corp. The company publishes hundreds of millions of tweets every day which the original inventor described as bursts of inconsequential information like the chirps of birds. That’s an insult to avian intelligence and the communicative skills of birds.
As for the Twitter and X corporation’s products, what’s been consequential for them is they have been loss-making for all but two years of their 18-year history. The company’s revenues have also been dropping for the past three years, so the losses have been growing.1
This oughtn’t to be surprising once you learn that one tweet in every five is a fake which has been created, not by a single human being trying to communicate to another, but by a machine generating text automatically, or by groups of human beings using their machines to “peddle propaganda and disinformation to those attempting to sell products, induce website clicks, push phishing attempts or malware, manipulate stocks or cryptocurrencies, and harass or intimidate users of the platform.”2
Truth is an antidote, and there are many standards of truth telling. The two usually relied upon are the criminal court test for murder which requires the evidence to be credible beyond reasonable doubt; and the civil court test for fraud which is weighed on the balance of probabilities. In the time of the wars we are living through now, there is plenty of murder and of fraud, so both standards are recommended for judging every tweet.
However, there is a third standard –truth by retrospection. This is the clock test against which propaganda, no matter how persuasive at the start, is proved to be false by the elapse of time to the end. Was the Ukraine winning its war against Russia? – that tweeted question can finally be judged on the day after the regime in Kiev has signed the capitulation documents and accepted the loss of its armies and borders.
(more…)




















